|
Chapter 9
Topographic Delineation
Fabrication Principles for Hand Laminated Seat Cushions - Posterior
Quadrants -
As part of the thinking process for constructing a seat cushion
we know that we can amend pressure distribution, body orientation
and skeletal alignment by manipulating the surface topography and
immersion qualities of a cushion. And, as part of this effort we set
goals to intentionally control, circumvent, support and distort the
shape of soft tissues. We do this based upon our knowledge of
anatomy, physics and physical disability combined with an acute
understanding of the potential negative consequences of our actions.
However, one of the biggest mistakes made interpreting the
appropriateness of a contoured or molded seating system lies with
the assessor's inability to scrutinize the total construct of the
structure, relative to the specific seating requirements of the
consumer. Using a seating simulator or foam-in-place appliance can
help to create shapes that envelop and provides postural stability
as well as skin protection but do the intimately fitting contours of
the finished product really address issues of faulty biomechanics?
As seating specialist, can we quantify the effectiveness of sculpted
shapes relative to a specific list of needs? ...In short; we can,
through a uniform understanding of the individual and collective
influence that geometric shapes have on obligatory sitting posture.
The key to this entire discussion about the core elements of seat
construction is that the basic principles to controlling pelvic
stability, orientation, alignment and position, while at the same
time insuring skin integrity, do not change no matter what physical
profile you find in the superincumbent body structures. And, yes, it
is possible to design a safe environment for skin integrity and
postural stability within the construct of a cushion made
exclusively with foam.
Background
The term "Topographic Delineations" can be interpreted in several
ways: as individual structures in the landscape of a cushion (such
as an ischial recess or posterior pelvic support), as distinct areas
of the landscape (such as a quadrant or region) or as a specific
cross sectional profile of the cushion (such as a single digitized
outline or specified cross-sectional delineation). The point is that
by delineating the topography of a cushion (any cushion) the
observer can define in detail, the function, benefit and structural
requirements of each convoluting shape. By contrast, the collective
goal of the "Topographic Delineation Fabrication Process" is to
create a predefined support surface environment that is predictive
yet retains conformable and enveloping qualities. The cornerstone of
this fabrication process is that it ensures ample pressure
redistribution for the maintenance of tissue integrity.
The dimensional specifications and geometric formulas for each of
the Topographic Delineations described in Chapters 9, 10, 11 and 12
were first cataloged in 1983. The formulas which are based upon anthropometric
extrapolations hold true no matter the
size or lack of symmetry of the consumer or that of the finished
product. They also remain unchanged whether the end product is hand
laminated, robotically sculpted or manufactured using any Solid Freeform
Fabrication technique. This consistency allows us to
build a system to the specific anthropometric and orthopedic
requirements of any wheelchair dependant person. The detailed
proprietary specifications of these Topographic Delineations are
however, not within the scope of the following discussions. We will
instead speak of them in general terms. Also note that not all of
the following are intended to be mixed and matched at will. It is
the responsibility of the seating specialist to select, apply and
evaluate the individual elements and appropriateness of the
completed design.
Foundations
There are several foundations that must be discussed in more detail
before we proceed to the specifics of the posterior quadrants. These
foundations influence the weight, thickness and dynamic flexibility of
the finished product. There are also several modifications not
discussed here, such as the drop seat and split front seat because the
core of current Rehab wheelchair designs has rendered them relatively
obsolete.
The Solid Base (Plinth)
The purpose of the plinth is to ensure consistent performance from the
cushion; principally to prevent bowing or deformation of the foam
structure while supporting the weight of the occupant. In the early
years of the industry the plinth also served as an anchoring platform
for vacuum formed or machine sewn upholstery covers. The rear profile
of a solid seat base can be rectangular, curved, or include a growth
tail projection. The solid base should be at least 1 1/2" longer than the
measured length of the thighs. The additional length represents the
portion of the seat which lies directly beneath the backrest and which
can be extended further if a growth tail is included.
The lateral edges of the solid base are usually parallel except
when accommodating excessively abducted thigh alignments. Sometimes
the lateral profile includes notches to allow close-in placement of
hip panels on a planar cushion. This too is considered an optional
growth feature.
The front edge the seat should be perpendicular to the thighs and
reflect their transverse alignment. So, as the thighs are fixed more
into abduction, the seat's front edge (at the popliteal fossa) will
reflect the diverging alignments. The front edge will also reflect
the existence of a leg length discrepancy or include a cutback to
accommodate an extreme hip extension variance. Front edge corner
notches are cutouts made into the plinth that accommodate the leg
hangers of the wheelchair frame. This modification is required
whenever the seat rails of the wheelchair are too short to
accommodate the entire length of the cushion. There are other
profiles that can be added to the solid base but there is only one
that will not be apparent while looking solely at the plinth. It is
the front edge undercut. It can very in length but its purpose is to
provide accommodation for knee flexion contractures or provide room
for the top edge of AFO's.
Keep in mind that with the current design criteria established by
Medicare/SADMERC(1) the plinth is considered redundant to the solid
pans which are now a basic component to many wheelchair
configurations; "There is no separate payment for a solid insert
that is used with a seat or back cushion because a solid base is
included in the allowance for a wheelchair seat or back
cushion... There is no separate payment when this is used with other
types of power wheelchairs (K0010, K0011, K0014) because those
wheelchairs include a solid seat pan."
Foam-Only Base
The foam-only base has evolved full circle over the decades. Prior
to its introduction a truly orthopedic seat cushion included a
separate plywood structure to rest upon. The intent of the base was
to counter the negative consequences of sling upholstery on folding
wheelchairs, such as: bowing of the cushion, internal rotation of
the hips, ischial and coccyx weight bearing, slouching, sliding and
posterior pelvic tilt, to name a few. Many current Rehab wheelchairs
(both power and manual) now include a rigid pan as a standard
feature.
The original foam-only base introduced by the Palo Alto REC was
built into the VASIO-P cushion (Veterans Administration Seating
Interface Orthosis) but later describe as a feature that could be
fabricated for any type cushion. Soon after it quickly became a key
feature for many manufacturers and cushion suppliers. Both designs
exhibited a profile that complimented the sling upholstery of a
folding wheelchair on its undersurface and a flat platform on its
top surface for the cushion to rest on, without risk of bowing. Now,
with a pan to rest on, the foam-only base consists of a half-inch
thick layer of closed cell foam and serves as a lightweight
substitute for a plywood base. The added advantage of the foam-only
base is that it can be notched or modified further to accommodate
any irregularities on the surface of the pan. A major drawback is
that accessories, such as hip panels and flip down pommels, must now
be attached directly to the pan; a sometimes tedious process that
requires additional (non-billable) labor.
Sub-Base Lamination
The sub-base lamination can serve several functions: first, as a
protective layer to prevent bottoming-out as the top layers soften;
secondly, as a protective mechanism to dampen vertical perturbation;
and finally, as the first opportunity to introduce pressure
redistribution and load deflection qualities to the seating
environment. Placing an additional protective layer below the core
elements of a cushion allows the support structures to remain in
close proximity to the contact surface. In this way the surface
structure and topographic delineations maintain their integrity more
so than if the top layer was thicker.
Pressure redistribution and load deflection qualities at the
sub-base can be placed anywhere within the four quadrants and can
serve to encourage the cushion to flex or deflect for specific
reasons: minimize pressure resistance, ease transfers, ease weight
shifts for pressure redistribution or facilitate the shift of
COG/COM for the performance of a task. The thickness of a sub-base
lamination is dictated by the size and shape of the consumer, the
shape of the cushion (planar versus contoured/molded) and intended
goals of the seating specialist. See Chapter 8 for additional
insight about foam altering and lamination techniques.
The Structural Components of the Posterior
Quadrants
If we agree that the pelvis represents the cornerstone structure
of all seating alignment, stability and equilibrium goals then it
should also follow that the seat cushion is the foundation on which
this cornerstone finds its sure footing. Looking further within the
cushion structure, it is the posterior half of the seat that most
defines whether pelvic orientation and stability can be maintained
sufficiently to provide a consistent, reliable foundation for the
alignment and postural maintenance of all other body segments.
Of the 12 voluntary or involuntary movements possible for pelvic
alignment in sitting (6 directional, 6 axial), the seat cushion can
control, restrict or influence eleven. Of these, nine are restricted
or controlled most significantly by the structures found within the
posterior quadrants of the seat and without any assistance from the
backrest. The tenth (posterior pelvic tilt) is controlled by the buttock/thigh elevation on the seat but more effectively controlled by the
posterior pelvic support of the backrest.
The eleventh (anterior pelvic tilt) is restricted by the profile at the anterior quadrants
and/or chest strap/harness and/or lap tray. The twelfth (pelvic elevation) is not influenced in any way by the seat but rather a lap
belt, ASIS bar or other anterior pelvic apparatus.
To better understand (in a tangible sense) how a seat cushion can
restrict or control the pelvis to such a degree, the landscape of a
seat cushion is first delineated into quadrants. It is the
topography and composition of each quadrant that will dictate the
stability, control and orientation of the pelvic and lower limbs.
This perspective may not be so obvious when observing symmetry in
the posterior quadrants of a cushion however as we introduce
asymmetric physical anomalies, especially in the anterior quadrants,
it becomes very conspicuous.
The following are anatomy supporting seat structures of the rear
quadrants that control pelvic stability, equilibrium, orientation
and stationary alignment while promoting tissue integrity and
pressure displacement. As we speak of these structures keep in mind
that it is the rear quadrants of a cushion that dictates the height
of the head above the floor. More specifically, head height is
dictated by the suspended height of the ischial tuberosities. In a
contoured or molded seat cushion the area below the ischial
tuberosities is usually the thinnest part of the cushion yet thick
enough (sub-base lamination) to prevent bottoming out as the cushion
runs through its load deflection lifecycle.
Growth Tail
The foam component of a growth tail is little more than an
extension of the posterior profile of a seat cushion and has a
practical length of only three inches. Its function is to allow the
pelvis to position farther rearward as femoral length of a growing
child increases. Its inclusion however, restricts the type or degree
of foam profiles that can be built into the posterior quadrants. For
example, a Buttock/Thigh Recess is no longer feasible and a pelvic
obliquity contour must be used with caution (see descriptions
below). If these features are still desired then the cushion will
require multiple or extensive modifications to allow growth
accommodation later on.
Here's a side note: some wheelchair designs (such as the Quickie,
Iris) force the inclusion of a growth tail like feature at the rear
of a seat cushion when the push handles are aligned into an open
seat-to-back angle. The current frame design has a forward facing
adjustment dial that projects above the seat rails when the push
handles are tilted to an open angle. Another work-around is to use
spacers to elevate the cushion above the raised metal obstruction
but that may not be practical in all scenarios.
Ischial Cutout
In the early days of pressure sore prevention research (roughly
1965 - 1980) the ischial cutout was sited as a favorable tool for
reducing ischial pressures to below the capillary flow threshold of
32mm Hg. By using this design feature it is also possible to achieve
total ischial suspension with zero compression force. There are
sheer stress side effects, however, when encouraging such intense
pressure transitions in such a confined area (from zero underneath
the ischii to higher than typical beneath the trochanters and
posterior thighs). Cushions designed with this feature also tend to
have a short lifecycle due to the accelerated loss of cushion
integrity and the collapse of the inner walls of the cutout. The
ischial cutout is still in use today with several modifications
added to smooth out the pressure transition and increase the
cushion's lifecycle. The ischial cutout is usually incorporated in
planar cushions constructed with 3" or 4" thick, 4-pound density
polyurethane. The lifespan of the finished product is usually 9 to
12 months, depending on manner of use and exposure to the elements.
NOTE: The 3" to 4" cushion thickness requirement
for ischial suspension is consistent with the combination of ischial
depth in sitting (for the average adult) of approximately 2 1/2" and
typical foam compression of a 4-pound density, 16" X 16" seat
cushion.
Pre-ischial bar
Later in the research at Rancho Los Amigos Hospital in Downey,
CA (RLAH), the pre-ischial bar was added as one technique for
smoothing the pressure transition between the ischii and the sub-trochanteric
structures. It also helped to further reduce forward migration of
the pelvic by increasing the height of the shelf anterior to the
ischial tuberosities. Its design is an elevated surface made of the
same foam material, measuring from 1/2" to 1" thick and laminated in
roughly a 4" deep by full width section to the front portion of the
cushion. The pre-ischial bar is positioned at the leading edge of
the ischial cutout. This stair step profile lowers pressure
underneath the trochanters and transfers more load to the mid
portion of the posterior thighs. The biggest misunderstanding about
the application of this feature is that it is never used alone as is
attempted by the design of the Anti-Thrust Seat. (2) (See below and
Chapter 10 for a list of concerns)
Ischial Recess
As the understanding of ischemic ulcers and pressure thresholds were
better understood it became clearer, through continued clinical
observations and research at RLAH that each body structure had its
own threshold of ischemic tolerance. Consequently, following the
RLAH clinical guidelines, the REC in Palo Alto, CA, laid plans to
explore a seat cushion configuration based upon the following:
14mm Hg at the coccyx
40mm Hg under the ischii
60 mm Hg under the trochanters
80+mm Hg under the posterior thighs
After writing a grant, the REC, in conjunction with
the VAMC in Palo Alto, CA, embarked upon a four year study of
several contoured cushion designs targeted towards SCI consumers and
based on the concept of "selective repartitioning". The key
component of the design was later defined as the Ischial Recess and
today has become an integral design component for many commercial
products.
The structure of the ischial recess can be shaped in
two manners: with or without a perineal trough. Without the trough
the recess projects from the rear of the cushion forward to just
anterior of the peri-ischial profile. The shape is mostly
rectangular, akin to the ischial cutout but with sloped and radius
edges to smooth out pressure transitions. With the perineal trough
the recess projects forward with an elliptical profile (akin to a
commode seat) to an area just forward of the genitals. The perineal
trough is intended to promote aeration to the pelvic floor, allow
the evacuation of moisture and reduce pressure on the perineum and
peri-ischial structures. Again, the thickness of the recess is
dictated by the decision of how much ischial pressure relief
(suspension) and pelvic registry is required.
As part of the research in Palo Alto cantilever
postings were placed anterior to the trochanters to further reduce
pressure readings on the ischial tuberosities. However, during
trials it was demonstrated that the anterior postings had to be used
with caution as one of the drawbacks is that an unopposed rise,
anterior to the trochanters, can have a negative fulcrum effect and
actually increase the load to the ischii. To balance out this
consequence another more pronounced set of postings were sculpted
into the cushion profile at each posterior corner to support the
posterolateral aspects of the buttocks and later defined as the
buttock thigh elevation. These combined changes became significant
features for the success of the project.
However, the ischial recess is not just for ischial
suspension and pressure redistribution. It also functions to provide
consistent registry and orientation for the pelvis. In fact, that is
its primary purpose in pediatrics where the potential for tissue
trauma is not of principle concern but symmetrical skeletal
development is.
NOTE: The three previously mentioned
Topographic Delineations are intended for use with a pelvis that can
achieve midline registry in the frontal plane and does not have
fixed Y-axis rotation (right or left pelvic obliquity). Transverse
rotation (Z-axis), on the other hand, can be easily accommodated for
through detailed refinements. Each of the above also encourage
external hip rotation through the combination of ischial immersion,
increased support pressure to the posterior thighs and improved
tibial alignment (vertical). Of the nine pelvic movements
controlled, restricted or influenced at the posterior quadrants of
the seat the ischial cutout and ischial recess are effective with
eight.
Pelvic Obliquity Contour
The pelvic obliquity contour can vary from as little as a 1/2" to
an excess of 4" and is the most difficult topographic delineation to
describe or fabricate by hand.
Let"s first clarify that there are two distinctly different types
of obliquity which sometimes combine to add even more complexity to
achieving the goals of tissue integrity, accommodation and support.
They are: axial obliquity in the frontal plane and axial obliquity
in the transverse plane. In the frontal plane the elevated hip may
be a result of a hip extension contracture and require a seat
profile with a foam wedge that is higher at the rear to support the
buttocks but diminishes anteriorly to support the affected thigh at
or below the level of the opposite knee. Transverse obliquity is
usually accompanied by unilateral hip extension and hip dislocation/subluxation
on the contralateral side and consequential leg length discrepancy.
With the exception of the high side femoral angle and contralateral
trochanter depression there is no single formula that can blindly
represent these abnormalities. Only through a body mold can the
profile be accurately measured and replicated via hand lamination,
foam-in-box construction or digital carving. In any case, the
resulting cushion profile will reflect asymmetry in all four
quadrants. (See also my concerns listed in Chapter 6)
With the presence of pelvic obliquity the distinct anatomical
profiles that can be recognized and measured are: the high-side
femoral angle, and location and depth of the low-side ischium and
trochanter indentations. Additionally, the goal for pelvic obliquity
support should not be to align the knees to equal elevation but to
provide maximum stability and pressure displacement within the full
topography of the cushion.
Buttock/Thigh Elevation (Recess)
Depending on how you view cushion structures this peripheral
delineation is either a recess (carving downward through a block of
foam) or an elevation (laminating upward). Though the buttock/thigh
elevation can be used separately, its profile is intended to
compliment and enhance the principle functions of the ischial recess
through pressure redistribution and pelvic containment. Throughout
its raised surface, along the lateral and posterior perimeter of the
seat, it makes contact at the lateral aspects of the buttocks and
thighs. More contact means more pressure redistribution. The
posterior corner elevations further enhance pelvis stability by
containing the soft tissue of the buttocks to a restricted range of
movement. When placed above an Ischial recess the posterior profile
of the B/T elevation diverts and coincidently avoids pressure
against the distal sacrum and coccyx region. This combination of
structured profiles also serves to compliment the function of the
posterior pelvic support and discourage posterior pelvic tilt.
Unlike hip panels, the height of the B/T elevation
rarely exceeds two inches when it accompanies an ischial recess,
anti-thrust wedge or pelvic obliquity contour. The reason is that
thigh control is largely achieved by allowing the pelvis to drop
below the pre-ischial shelf of the cushion, which in turn increases
containment of the femurs. Any additional height required near the
lateral aspect of the knees can be achieved by adding built-in knee
or hip adductor guides superior to the B/T elevation (see Chapter
10). This combination may require a rigid enforcement on the lateral
aspect of the cushion for those who exhibit strong abduction. The
B/T elevation can be constructed with full symmetry or shaped to
compliment transverse pelvic obliquity. It can also be constructed
in a half length profile to facilitate lateral transfers or to
provide the thighs more freedom for lateral movement and/or abducted
positioning. Finally, the B/T elevation can exhibit a trochanter
relief for robust or dislocated hips.
Here are a couple of points to keep in mind about
the B/T elevation; it may not be compatible with a body jacket or
other spinal orthosis (TLSO) because their lower posterior trim
lines may conflict and push the occupant anteriorly; the B/T
elevation will affect the overall vertical length and vertical
placement of the backrest; the B/T elevation should not be used with
hip/pelvic flexion angles of less than 65º as it may conflict with
the pelvis' ability to position into posterior tilt.
Buttock-Well
This structural delineation is actually a composite of two
others: the B/T elevation and anti-thrust wedge (see Chapter 10).
The buttock-well composition is used as a generic support feature
for the entire buttocks when little information is known about the
actual anatomical profile of the consumer. Consequently, its affect
on encouraging pelvic symmetry and pressure redistribution away from
the ischial tuberosities is minimal. As a popular feature on many
commercial seat cushions its greatest affect is to control M/L and
A/P pelvic migration.
__________________________
For the wheelchair dependant consumer sitting is a lifelong
requirement for every aspect of living. In sitting, the alignment of
the pelvis is the cornerstone that dictates the posture for the rest
of the body. Also, whether the consumer is or is not vulnerable to
pressure ulcers the repartitioning of ischemic pressure away from
the ischii, coccyx and sacrum is paramount for long-term comfort and
upper body stability.
The need to include air cells or gel bladders in custom seating
designs is quite likely an indication that the shape and structural
composition of the cushion are flawed to begin with. Understanding
why, when and how a predefined topographic delineation works can
make the difference between recurring success and repeated trial and
error.
Balance, stability, equilibrium and poise are all valued elements
of not only good posture but functional posture as well. It is the
shape of the rear quadrants of a seat cushion that dictates the
shape of every other profile of a seating system and ultimately the
posture of functional living. I cannot stress enough that as a
seating specialist, how you delineate the shapes of the rear
quadrants lays the groundwork for every other task you encounter
with complex seating designs. Understand this and the art of custom
seating manufacturing begins to look a bit more like science.
© Copyright August 15, 2005 - CUSHMAKER.com
.
-
1) http://www.cignamedicare.com/dmerc/lmrp_lcd/WCS-Art.html
2) http://www.vard.org/jour/01/38/4/pdf/sprigle.pdf
Return to Table
of Contents
Return to Articles page
|